Asus P5K3 Premium: Part 2

August 29, 2007 | 11:08

Tags: #analysis #benchmark #ddr3 #p5k3 #performance #premium #results #testing

Companies: #asus

Xvid Encoding:

We tested video encoding performance using VirtualDub-MPEG version 1.6.15 and a multi-threaded version of the Xvid codec, along with the LAME MT MP3 encoder for encoding audio. We did a two-pass encode of a 15-minute 276MB digital TV recording with a target file size of 100MB.

Xvid Encoding

VirtualDub MPEG-2 1.6.15, Xvid 1.2 beta, 276MB .mpg to 100MB .avi

  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1500MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • 734.3
  • 747.3
  • 716.7
  • 739.7
  • 726.7
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Time in Seconds (lower is better)

There isn't that much between them all, although the 1,500MHz memory does afford a slightly better performance by some 10-20 seconds. The times are actually reversed between the Premium with its slightly faster low latency 1,066MHz score and faster Deluxe at 1,333MHz.

MP3 Encoding:

We used LAME MT for our audio encoding test - it's the multi-threaded version of the popular LAME MP3 encoder. We ran tests with both Intel's and Microsoft's compilers - naturally, the Intel compiler resulted in some performance increases on Intel's processors. We converted all 18 tracks from Moby's popular Play album to a 192kbps variable bit-rate MP3.

MP3 Encoding (Intel)

LAME 3.97, Moby - Play, .wav to 192KHz .mp3, Intel Compiler

  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1500MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • 113.3
  • 113.7
  • 115.0
  • 114.7
  • 114.7
0
25
50
75
100
125
Time in Seconds (lower is better)

MP3 Encoding (Microsoft)

LAME 3.97, Moby - Play, .wav to 192KHz .mp3, MS Compiler

  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1500MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • 124.3
  • 123.7
  • 125.7
  • 126.3
  • 124.0
0
25
50
75
100
125
Time in Seconds (lower is better)

Across the board memory bandwidth or latency seems to make very little difference on MP3 encoding times.

MP3 Decoding


MP3 Decoding (Intel)

LAME 3.97, Moby - Play, .192KHz .mp3 to .wav, Intel Compiler

  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1500MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • 41.3
  • 44.0
  • 41.3
  • 46.0
  • 46.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Time in Seconds (lower is better)

MP3 Decoding (Microsoft)

LAME 3.97, Moby - Play, .192KHz .mp3 to .wav, MS Compiler

  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Premium (E6750, 1500MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6700, 1066MHz Memory)
  • Asus P5K3 Deluxe (E6750, 1333MHz Memory)
  • 40.0
  • 38.7
  • 39.7
  • 42.7
  • 39.0
0
10
20
30
40
Time in Seconds (lower is better)

Decoding times are a bit more random, with the Premium coming out more or less better over all, however the 1,333MHz memory score on both boards goes from slowest to fastest between Intel and Microsoft compiled LAME's respectively. The results are all averaged from three scores, so the effect of Vista's background services should be smoothed out. Decoding is more a product of hard drive write speed, too, though the boards seemed to have similar figures for that - but either way, the memory is unlikely the reason for the behaviour.
Discuss this in the forums
YouTube logo
MSI MPG Velox 100R Chassis Review

October 14 2021 | 15:04